Citizen's Quill

I haven’t said much about this. Mostly because I was stunned at the sheer use of force like this in an American city by the US government. In the early morning hours of September 30, 2025, in Chicago’s South Shore community residents of a five-story apartment building were violently awakened by an operation that looked less like law enforcement and more like a military occupation. Black Hawk helicopters – BLACK HAWKS – hovered overhead, federal agents rappelled from rooftops, flashbangs went off, and armed personnel in military fatigues stormed through doors. They forcibly removed men, women, and screaming children from their homes in the middle of the night. This traumatic display, described by witnesses as an “invasion,” was not a scene from an authoritarian regime abroad, but here in the heart of the United States. It was part of the Trump Administration’s “Operation Midway Blitz,” an initiative that has seen a dramatic escalation of federal tactics. It raises profound questions about constitutional overreach and the alarming creep of authoritarianism in America.

Do we still have a Constitution?

The South Shore raid, which resulted in 37 arrests and the detention of numerous individuals, including U.S. citizens, flagrantly challenged fundamental constitutional protections.

• Fourth Amendment – Protection Against Unreasonable Searches and Seizures: Federal agents “burst through doors using flashbang grenades” and that “multiple U.S. citizens were detained for hours without warrants or legal justification” (Tietz, 2025). Eyewitness Pertissue Fisher, a U.S. citizen, recounted being handcuffed and held for hours despite having no warrants (MSN(2), 2025). When agents sweep an entire residential building, detaining everyone regardless of their status or specific warrant, it constitutes a general search and seizure, violating the Fourth Amendment’s requirement for individualized probable cause and specific warrants.
• Fifth Amendment – Due Process and Liberty: The detention of U.S. citizens without immediate charges or clear legal justification, and forced separation of children from their parents, are a significant strike at the core of due process. The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) confirmed that “four children who are U.S. citizens with undocumented parents were taken into custody” (MSN (1,2), 2025). NAACP president Derrick Johnson condemned this, stating, “The trauma inflicted on these young people and their families is unconscionable” (MSN(1), 2025). These actions erode the fundamental right to liberty and family integrity guaranteed by the Fifth Amendment.
• Tenth Amendment – States’ Rights and Federalism: Illinois Governor J.B. Pritzker strongly the federal actions, stating, “Military-style tactics should never be used on children in a functioning democracy” and that federal agents “fail to focus on violent criminals and instead create panic in our communities” (MSN (1,2), 2025). Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson called ICE’s tactics “abusive” (MSN(1), 2025). The federal government’s deployment of aggressive tactics within a state’s authority, overriding local sentiment and authority, represents a significant challenge to the delicate balance of power between federal and state governments.

Normalization of “Military-Style Tactics” on Civilians

The methods employed in the Chicago raid were consistently described as “military-style,” a stark departure from traditional civilian policing. Darrell Ballard, a neighbor, stated, “I’ve been on military bases for a good portion of my life… And the activity I saw – it was an invasion” (MSN(1), 2025). The presence of Black Hawk helicopters, agents rappelling from rooftops, and the use of flashbangs and armed agents in military fatigues are not tools of community policing but of warfare (MSN(1), 2025, Tietz, 2025).

Governor Pritzker’s pointed remark, “This didn’t happen in a country with an authoritarian regime – it happened here in Chicago. It happened in the United States of America – a country that should be a bastion of freedom,” underscores the deeply troubling nature of these tactics (MSN(1), 2025). When federal agencies deploy overwhelming and intimidating force against civilian populations, particularly against residents in their homes, it erodes public trust and normalizes the use of extreme measures in domestic law enforcement.

Broader Implications – Redefining Domestic Law Enforcement

President Trump’s rhetoric preceding these operations provides chilling context. He spoke of a “war from within” the nation, stating, “We are under invasion from within… no different than a foreign enemy, but more difficult in many ways, because they don’t wear uniforms” (MSN(1), 2025). He called for U.S. cities to be “training grounds” for the military and threatened Chicago with a “Department of War,” planning to deploy the National Guard to crack down on crime and immigration enforcement (MSN(1), 2025).

This language blurs the critical distinction between external military threats and internal civilian issues, effectively transforming American cities into battlegrounds and citizens into potential combatants. This clearly signals a dangerous shift where federal agencies, including those traditionally focused on border security like Border Patrol, are increasingly deployed with military-grade equipment and tactics against residents far from any border. The militarization of domestic law enforcement threatens to redefine civil liberties and the very nature of governance in U.S. cities.

A Pretext for Mass Detention?

DHS justified the South Shore raid by claiming the building was “known to be frequented by Tren de Aragua members and their associates” (MSN(1, 2), 2025). However, the reality of the arrests paints a different picture. Only TWO individuals out of 37 arrested were confirmed as suspected gang members; others were detained for various criminal records, including marijuana possession, or, as with U.S. citizens, without a specific warrant (Tietz, 2025).

This disparity suggests that the alleged presence of a few gang members was used as a pretext to conduct a broad, indiscriminate raid on an entire residential building. Such “fishing expeditions” – using generalized accusations to justify mass detentions – are a hallmark of authoritarian systems designed to instill fear and control, rather than targeted, constitutionally sound law enforcement. The disproportionate force used for such a minimal number of confirmed targets raises serious questions about the true intent behind the operation.

Nationalizing the National Guard: Authoritarianism

Adding to these concerns are President Trump’s repeated threats to deploy the National Guard to cities like Chicago and his discussions about making greater use of the U.S. military in American cities (MSN(1), 2025). The National Guard typically operates under state command, with governors serving as their commanders-in-chief, unless federalized under specific, limited circumstances.

A unilateral decision by the President to nationalize a state’s National Guard and deploy it within that state against the will of its governor represents an unprecedented federal power grab and is just one in a long list from this administration. It bypasses state sovereignty, undermines the constitutional roles of both federal and state governments, and is a use of military force against American citizens without the consent of their elected state leadership. Such a move would be a severe blow to federalism and a significant step toward concentrating military power under executive control for domestic purposes.

This Is Fascism

These actions – the erosion of constitutional rights, the militarization of domestic law enforcement, the demonization of specific groups, and the disregard for democratic norms and state sovereignty – bear alarming resemblances to the incremental steps often seen in the rise of authoritarian regimes, including the early stages of Hitler’s rise to power.

Hitler, too, consolidated power by demonizing “others” (ethnic minorities, political opponents) and portraying them as an “invasion from within.” He steadily eroded democratic institutions, used paramilitary forces (the SA and SS) to instill fear, and normalized violence and intimidation as tools of governance. The gradual blurring of lines between law enforcement and military action, the broad application of force against civilian populations based on generalized threats, and the executive’s expressed desire to override state authority are all concerning parallels.

Allowing these precedents to be set without strong public and political challenge is an alarming step to normalizing this authoritarian shift. When a government treats its own citizens and residents with the tactics of a foreign enemy, constitutional protections are disregarded, and militarized force becomes the answer to domestic issues, the foundations of a free society begin to crumble.

A Call to Vigilance

What unfolded in Chicago is not merely an incident of aggressive immigration enforcement; it is a profound indicator of a disturbing trajectory. It is a bullhorn call for vigilance and a strong defense of constitutional principles. We must actively scrutinize the actions of federal agencies, challenge the normalization of military tactics against civilians, and uphold the delicate balance of power that underpins our democracy. The lessons of history teach us that the erosion of freedom often begins with subtle shifts, and the “invasion from within” is a threat we must recognize and resist with unwavering resolve.

(1) MSN. (2025). Msn.com. https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/military-style-ice-raid-in-chicago-shows-escalation-in-tactics/ar-AA1NRDkZ?ocid=BingNewsSerp

(2) MSN. (2025). Msn.com. https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/37-people-arrested-and-american-kids-separated-from-parents-after-ice-raid-at-chicago-apartments/ar-AA1NORV0?ocid=BingNewsSerp

‌(3) Tietz, D. (2025, October 4). Federal Agents Storm Chicago Apartment Building in Nighttime Raid, Detaining 37 Including US Citizens – SJO Daily. SJO Daily -. https://sjodaily.com/2025/10/04/federal-agents-storm-chicago-apartment-building-in-nighttime-raid-detaining-37-including-us-citizens/

‌